The year is 1972. Houston, Texas serial killer Dean Corll (Edward X. Young) along with his teenage accomplices Wayne Henley (Eric Fleising) and David Brooks (Seth Leighton Hale) are in Chicago attending a candy convention when they meet up with Chicago's own serial killer John Gacy (Jeremy Woodworth). Both Corll and Gacy set their sites on the same teenage victim. But instead of competing over him, they decide to mutually capture him and then discuss the best way to dispatch him. Back at Corll's motel room, bonding and getting high and drunk on pot and beer, they exchange stories about their mutual psychopathic past times, their best triumphs and kills. Tales of Gacy's fascinating habit of entertaining children as Pogo the Clown, as well as Corll's infamous teenage pot and glue sniffing parties come to light as ways of procuring innocent male teenage victims whom they both enjoyed molesting, torturing and killing. Their captive teen listens with increasing panic as their stories detail some of the most horrific and depraved murders incomprehensible to most normal people. But soon Dean Corll and John Gacy realize they have less in common than they originally thought. They begin to argue over how the murder of their captive teen should happen, which soon escalates to an all out Texas style fisticuffs brawl. However, it all comes to an abrupt end when Charles Manson (John Link) intervenes.