Nick and Charlie will soon be celebrating their nine month anniversary. However, Charlie feels uncomfortable with what he sees as Nick leading other men on, regardless of if Nick doesn't act on it. Nick admits that his own insecurities need that validation of knowing that he is desirable to other men. But when Charlie catches Nick out with one of those men on the day of their nine month anniversary, they will have to come to an understanding of their situation if there will be a nine month plus one day for them.