A reward is offered for the capture of Broncho Billy and David Kirkland and freedom is promised to either one who will turn state's evidence. Broncho and Dave are pals, but they fall out over a pretty Indian girl and Dave, who is jealous of Broncho Billy's success in winning the favor of the girl, tells the sheriff where to find Billy, and the latter is captured. Dave then writes a letter to the Indian girl under Billy's name and tells her that he is going away and cannot marry her. Fifteen years later Billy is released from prison and finds White Feather, the once pretty Indian girl, a gray-haired, worn-out squaw. She tells him that she became the wife of Dave and that he had deserted her. Billy sets out to get Dave, who has become a roving gambler. In the little town of Sennet, Dave has succeeded in getting the postmaster and storekeeper in his power and won his consent to let Dave marry his daughter Grace. The girl is engaged to a young ranchman, but agrees to marry Dave to save her father from disgrace. Just as the wedding is about to be performed, Billy comes on the scene with White Feather and several Indians of her tribe. Kirkland is exposed and is taken away by the Indians. Ned is sent for and marries Grace and Broncho Billy is happy.