Bart McGrew, a rascally schemer, endeavors to secure an old Indian chief's signature to a deed that will give him thousands of acres of valuable land owned by the tribe. Laughing Fawn, the chief's beautiful daughter, suspects Bart of treachery and takes her father away before he signs. Later McGrew finds the old chief in the town saloon trying to buy whiskey, which is refused him. McGrew secures a bottle of liquor, gets the Indian in the back room, plies him with the fiery stuff until he is intoxicated, then endeavors to secure his signature to the paper. Laughing Fawn comes in search of her father, realizes, the situation, tears up the deed and is seized by the infuriated ruffian. Her screams attract the attention of Broncho Billy, who is playing cards in the outer room. He rushes in, covers McGrew with his six-shooter, sends Laughing Fawn and her father away, warns McGrew to stop his evil scheme and backs out the door. Burning with revenge, McGrew follows Broncho to his cabin and is about to kill him through the open window, when he in turn is slain by a shot from Laughing Fawn's revolver. Broncho learns the Indian maid has saved his life, discharges a shell in McGrew's gun, also one in his own, and when the Sheriff arrives, explains McGrew was killed in self-defense. The sheriff examines the guns, is convinced Broncho tells the truth, and departs with the body, leaving Broncho and Laughing Fawn standing watching them out of sight down the dusty trail.