Old Tobias hires the psychologist Doctor Varlay to interview people about their desires. While flashbacks are shown of Young Tobias and Lilly, Doctor Varlay meets her interviewees. Laura reminisces about a joint meeting with her two boyfriends. Stand-up comedian John recalls dreaming of talking and touching a mannequin girl so much that she momentarily came to life. Next up, retired football player Fred recalls a random sex encounter, prompting the buxom doctor to fantasize of pleasuring him. Lastly, Kim fantasizes about her female roommate, prompting Doctor Varlay to imagine the same scenario with her assistant Carol. Kim also recalls a The Crying Game (1992) experience with a transsexual. Doctor Varlay then finds her real desire in Old Tobias' assistant, Carlos. Carol does the same with Fred. At Old Tobias' deathbed, a Lilly hallucination reveals she left him because he desired money over her.