In Wyoming, a feud is going on between the sheep herders and the cattlemen for control of the grazing lands. Five sheep-men have been found murdered, and each has had a mysterious stone between his eyes. Sheriff Red Agnew is a hireling of the sheep interests, which only adds to the conflict. Out inspecting the land for the cattlemen he represents, Bill Blunt encounters Hilma Ring, a sheep man's daughter of the "primitive" sort. Although Bill and Hilma are at first at odds with each other, eventually they reconcile and fall in love.